Stubborn Mistakes by Rose Cost Cougars Big

Let me preface this posting with this. I love Dave Rose as the basketball coach at BYU. He has done so much for this program and will continue to do so. However, he has some major flaws that some people just aren't willing to say.

Against Gonzaga and Saint Mary's, superior teams I might add, BYU has gotten out coached. Plain and simple.

While I believe and honestly know that Dave Rose is an excellent coach, he has made some enormous blunders as the leader of this team. Those mistakes cost BYU their shot at key victories this season.

BYU all season long is known for not committing to one particular form of defense. They rotate between manning up, a match up zone, 2-3 zone even a 1-3-1 zone. This is usually done by teams that can't "hang their hate on one particular thing," as one ESPN announcer mentioned during a recent broadcast. However, BYU is in zone a majority of their games. This is the biggest downfall of this team

Gonzaga time and time again found Kelly Olynyk in the soft spot of the zone and he made them pay. Gonzaga's big man lit the Cougars up, and not just in his scoring. Olynyk made quick decision at the free throw line, the soft spot of all zone defenses. His passing was crisp and quick. His shots were on the money, and his drives were strong and with a purpose.

Despite this showcase of shredding a zone, Dave Rose continued to go with it down the stretch, even when BYU made their final move with about 10 minutes left in the game. This was a fatal coaching decision. BYU had not stopped the 7 footer from beating them all game, yet they invited him to camp in the same spot over and over again, and he made them pay over and over again.

I am not sure why BYU thought that zone would work? It hadn't before against weaker competition, what did you expect from a legitimate top 5 team? Gonzaga is extremely well coached and disciplined, something BYU has to work on.

Secondly, Tyler Haws has had difficulty getting open, especially against the better teams on the cougars schedule. Which leads to my next problem with coach Roses offensive approach. Haws inability to get open.

While some may place this blame on Haws, I see it as Roses mistake. The same play is run at least 15 times to get Haws open, each time it being in vain. Gonzaga had that play scouted and were ready for it. Yet Rose did not make the adjustment to get Haws open in other ways. The nations 7th leading scorer had an awful game, where when he actually was able to catch the ball he forced up bad shots.

Against Saint Mary's, BYU showed their biggest weakness. Rebounding. This team is just not a good rebounding team. To compound that problem, zone defenses are extremely hard to get rebounds off of, considering the lack of player-for-player accountability. Yet, Rose stuck with the defense. Against the Geals I will admit it was an improved zone, but they still couldn't crash the glass.

All in all, I am not calling for Dave Roses head. Not by a long shot. He is an excellent coach. I just noticed these flaws in the last few games and they were driving me nuts. Anyone who has played basketball knows you can get open with the right play calls. Rose has had trouble finding those schematics.

Podcast - Robert Anae and KVN back?! What does it all mean?

With special guest Papa Bro, the Sports Bros talk about Anae's rehire, KVN coming back, and the possibilities for next year's football team.

The Failure of One

Yesterday's loss for the BYU Cougar football team showed evidence of one thing. Brandon Doman has utterly failed as the offensive coordinator at his Alma Mater.

Brandon Doman should be
on the hot seat after 2012 season

During the Cougars 20-14 defeat at the hands of WAC opponent San Jose State, BYU constantly failed to convert on 3rd downs and could not establish a running game. Ironically, the cougars first score came on a run by freshman Jamaal Williams. However after that 16 yard TD scamper by the freshman phenom, he only managed 46 yards the rest of the game.

Doman came into the position last season with lots of hype and promise. He has not panned out and he has not produced. Not even close.

Doman has created a lack of imagination in his play calling, not to mention a lack of ability. Ross Apo is only used in two situations throughout the season. The main one being a screen pass that never gets more than 7 yards, and failed deep balls that Riley Nelson cannot deliver on. Yet he continues to call these plays, and getting the same results. Nothing.

Yesterday BYU tried to run up the middle (which hadn't worked all game) on a third and short and on an attempted 4th down conversion. Both times Williams was stuffed for no gain or a short loss. Where is the imagination? Where is the sweep to utilize Williams' speed? The cougars had not proven the ability to run up the middle all game. Why does he think it would work then?

Another area Doman's lack of creativity and ability as a play caller has shown is in formations. If BYU is lined up in the I-formation the call is one of two things. A play action pass or a run. If an observer like myself can figure that out by game 2 of this lost season, what makes him think opposing defensive coordinators won't pick up on it? There is no creativity or imagination in this "great offensive" coordinator at BYU. He has lost something he never had in the first place. Ability as an offensive coordinator.

The play action for BYU has been abysmal this year primarily because of the lack of blocking and lack of talent at the quarterback position. Riley Nelson does not have the ability to make down the field throws, especially with the defense closing in on him.

Last of all, only being able to score 14 points against San Jose State is just not acceptable for a BYU offense. No disrespect to San Jose State, who lit BYU up in the first half, but the cougars should not have even let San Jose State stand a chance.

Riley Nelson continues to turn the ball over in the red zone (blue zone to you Cougar fans) and lose opportunities for points. the red zone play calling from Brandon Doman is the last area of ineptitude of the cougar play caller. He has failed to prove anything to anyone that he deserves to keep his job after the final horn sounds in San Diego later next month.

If I were a BYU fan, I would hope to look forward to seeing Brandon Doman off the sideline next season. There is too much talent on this BYU offense to be so awful.

Dont even get me started on the offensive line.

Getting Jabari Parker in Blue and White

I just wanted to use our yet small readership to promote and awesome movement of fans to help convince Jabari Parker to become a Cougar.

I try not to spend too much time on Cougarboard, but I found myself there and saw that they are starting a donation drive to buy shirts for the fans at the game Parker will be attending in the Marriott Center. The hope is that with a huge outpouring of support in Provo, Parker will see the light and put on the blue and white.

Here's the link.

All-Around Improvement Translates to Big Win for Cougars

Jamaal Williams and the BYU defense are rightly getting most of the praise for today's big win at Georgia Tech, but it was a great all-around performance that gave BYU it's most impressive win of the season. I saw improvement on almost every front.

First, Brandon Doman's play calling has consistently improved this year, and the Georgia Tech game was the best so far. The ESPNU commentator even exclaimed "gorgeous call!" as Riley Nelson dumped ball down to Williams as Georgia Tech's blitz came storming in from the edge. That play resulted in a 39 yard touchdown, William's fourth of the day. Doman did a good job of making Nelson's job as easy as possible, riding the back of Williams and mainly calling short passes and screens for Nelson. However, BYU broke two plays for 35+ yards, something the Cougars have struggled to do. Most importantly, Doman limited the called rushes for Nelson.

Second, and most surprisingly, the inexperienced offensive line held its own. Nelson looked relatively comfortable in the pocket and he was much more accurate without defensive ends breathing down his throat.

Third, Justin Sorensen missed a 25 yarder, but he made 2, which these days seems like gold.

Finally, Nelson himself seemed more collected, probably because he had more time thanks to the offensive line. Sure, he made his obligatory stupid play that resulted in a pick-6, but he settled in nicely and only ran out of the pocket only when absolutely necessary. 19/28 and 204 yards is not a bad night for him.

This game will probably be remembered as the Cougars' best showing of the season. And while this kind of improvement would have been useful in the close games BYU has lost, this was a badly needed win for a fan base frustrated by close losses.

Jamaal Williams Impresses Early On

A few months back after the open scrimmage BYU held toward the end of fall camp,I was talking to Big Bro about what I saw. I remember telling him there was a freshman that I thought was going to be a straight up stud for BYU for the next few years. I described his ability to get up-field quickly and make tacklers miss, all while holding onto the ball.

Yes, I was describing true freshman running back Jamaal Williams.

Jamaal Williams (21) had his best game against Hawaii

I was so excited to see this guy play in 2013. I was hoping he could sneak in a few snaps here and there to get some quality time in 2012. I even tweeted Jason Franchuck of the Daily Herald a few times to get his insights on the matter. Both of us agreed that he needed some field reps for him to be a consistent contributor. However, neither of us expected him to get the time and touches he has so far this season.

Jamaal Williams has been as good as advertised. He has shown the ability to catch the ball out of the back field, as well as take it between the tackles. He can get around the edge and make guys miss, not to mention lower his shoulder and lay some guys out. All to get an average of over 5 yards per carry. That's impressive for a senior running back. But this all coming from a guy who can't even vote on November 6.

I have thoroughly enjoyed watching Williams get more and more reps. This is happening partially due to the injury to Michael Alisa. However, even before Alisa's injury Williams was seeing the field for decent experience for a true freshman. He has proven to be one of the biggest offensive threats for BYU this season. He is only going to get more touches, and only going to get better.

I sure hope this kid stays healthy, and stays in Provo. If he does, I think we can all expect awesome things from Jamaal Williams. We have gotten a good glimpse of what he can do this year already. What more has he got to show us?

Podcast: Overrated Defense and Notre Dame preview

Is BYU's defense overrated, or did they just have a bad game? After getting exposed, see what Big Bro has to say about Bronco's defense moving forward.

Also, do we think BYU stands a shot at #5 Notre Dame?